By Douglas V. Gibbs
Author, Speaker, Instructor, Radio Host
-- Political Pistachio Conservative News and Commentary
Tuesday, February 26, 2019
Monday, February 25, 2019
Green New Deal and Ocasio Cortez Controls Democrats
By Douglas V. Gibbs
Author, Speaker, Instructor, Radio Host
Tucker Carlson discusses the Democrat Party's new idiotic socialist boss. . .
-- Political Pistachio Conservative News and Commentary
Author, Speaker, Instructor, Radio Host
Tucker Carlson discusses the Democrat Party's new idiotic socialist boss. . .
-- Political Pistachio Conservative News and Commentary
Sunday, February 24, 2019
Child Socialist in Congress Humiliated ... Again.
By Douglas V. Gibbs
Author, Speaker, Instructor, Radio Host
Rather than serve, she's trying to destroy, and her arguments are falling short, not only by facts, but by common sense. . .
Alexandria Ocasio Cortez:
-- Political Pistachio Conservative News and Commentary
Author, Speaker, Instructor, Radio Host
Rather than serve, she's trying to destroy, and her arguments are falling short, not only by facts, but by common sense. . .
Alexandria Ocasio Cortez:
-- Political Pistachio Conservative News and Commentary
Saturday, February 23, 2019
Constitution Radio: Civil War? Or Foreign Invasion?
Constitution Radio with
Douglas V. Gibbs: Saturday at
1:00 pm Pacific, KMET 1490-AM
○ First Hour: Constitution Radio with Doug, Alex, and Dennis discuss issues through the lens of the U.S. Constitution, with Alan Myers joining us late in the hour for a discussion regarding the monetary system.
○ Second Hour: Conservative Voice Radio with Doug, Glenn, Jan, and Diane to discuss the issues from a Tea Party perspective
KMET 1490-AM
1-3 pm on Saturday Afternoon
archived podcast at https://soundcloud.com/kmet-1490-am/sets/constitution-radio
Douglas V. Gibbs: Saturday at
1:00 pm Pacific, KMET 1490-AM
○ First Hour: Constitution Radio with Doug, Alex, and Dennis discuss issues through the lens of the U.S. Constitution, with Alan Myers joining us late in the hour for a discussion regarding the monetary system.
○ Second Hour: Conservative Voice Radio with Doug, Glenn, Jan, and Diane to discuss the issues from a Tea Party perspective
KMET 1490-AM
1-3 pm on Saturday Afternoon
archived podcast at https://soundcloud.com/kmet-1490-am/sets/constitution-radio
Friday, February 22, 2019
State of the Union Facts
By Douglas V. Gibbs
Author, Speaker, Instructor, Radio Host
Author, Speaker, Instructor, Radio Host
Now that the State of the Union is behind us, let's answer a few questions about it.
1. Is the State of the Union constitutionally required?
In Article II it states that the President of the United States "shall" deliver the State of the Union speech. However, it also says "from time to time," which means it is not required to be annual. That is tradition.
2. Does the State of the Union speech have to be delivered at the House of Representatives?
Article II states that the purpose of the State of the Union speech is to advise Congress, and make recommendations. Congress is both houses, the House, and the Senate. The Senate chamber is too small to accommodate all of the members of Congress, so The Capitol (where the House of Representatives meets) has been the traditional location because unlike the Senate, the floor of the House of Representatives is large enough to welcome all members of Congress, the Supreme Court, and other interested parties.
3. Can the Speaker of the House refuse to allow the President to give his speech in the House chambers?
Speaker Nancy Pelosi denied Trump the opportunity to deliver his State of the Union speech during the government shutdown, but gave in during the temporary cease-fire. According to Article I, Section 2 of the U.S. Constitution, the House may make its own rules regarding the manner and procedures associated with their part of government. One of those internal rules is that if the President is going to address them, he must be invited by the Speaker of the House. The tradition is long-standing. If the invitation is not given, it cannot be accepted.
-- Political Pistachio Conservative News and Commentary
Thursday, February 21, 2019
When did "Constitution" become a bad word?
By Douglas V. Gibbs
Author, Speaker, Instructor, Radio Host
Author, Speaker, Instructor, Radio Host
"What is it that your husband does," my wife's co-worker asked her.
"He's a constitutionalist," Mrs. Pistachio replied.
"Oh." Her friend's attitude suddenly went sour. "So, he likes Trump."
"Yes," was the reply. "He supports Trump."
"I don't like that man. I can't wait until he is no longer President."
---
I wish I had been there. First of all, I am willing to bet that if I asked, not a single dislike regarding Trump by that woman had anything to do with policy. Second, since when is the Constitution something to dislike?
The even more interesting thing is that I thought the Democrats were complaining because they thought Trump was acting in an unconstitutional manner, yet when my wife said I was a constitutionalist, the woman immediately assumed I was a Trump supporter. In other words, they know he's following the Constitution, and it is pissing them off.
When did the Constitution become a negative term with the Democrats? Or liberty, for that matter. Or, capitalism?
They are seriously beginning to sound like the Soviets did when I was growing up.
-- Political Pistachio Conservative News and Commentary
Tuesday, February 19, 2019
Reminder: No Corona Constitution Class Tonight
After a medical procedure I am having this afternoon we will not be meeting in Corona tonight for our weekly Constitution Class. See you next week.
Doug
Doug
Monday, February 18, 2019
Email of the Week: Hand of Hope
By Douglas V. Gibbs
Author, Speaker, Instructor, Radio Host
Author, Speaker, Instructor, Radio Host
Subject: Fwd: Picture Of Baby In Mother's Womb, Having Surgery For Spina Bifi
It should be "The Picture of the Year," or perhaps,
"Picture of the Decade." It won't be.
In fact, unless you obtained a copy of the US
paper which published it, you probably would never have
seen it. The picture is that of a 21-week-old unborn
baby named Samuel Alexander Armas, who is being
operated on by surgeon named Joseph Bruner.
The baby was diagnosed with spina bifida and
would not survive if removed from his mother's womb.
Little Samuel's mother, Julie Armas, is an obstetrics
nurse in Atlanta. She knew of Dr. Bruner's remarkable
surgical procedure. Practicing at Vanderbilt
University Medical Center in Nashville, he performs
these special operations while the baby is still in
the womb.
During the procedure, the doctor removes the
uterus via C-section and makes a small incision to
operate on the baby. As Dr. Bruner completed the
surgery on Samuel, the little guy reached his tiny,
but fully developed hand through the incision and
firmly grasped the surgeon's finger.
Dr. Bruner was reported as saying that when his finger was grasped,
it was the most emotional moment of his life, and that
for an instant during the procedure he was just
frozen, totally immobile.
The photograph captures this amazing event with
perfect clarity. The editors titled the picture, "Hand
of Hope." The text explaining the picture begins, "The
tiny hand of 21-week-old fetus Samuel Alexander Armas
emerges from the mother's uterus to grasp the finger of Dr. Joseph Bruner as
if thanking the doctor for the gift of life."
Little Samuel's mother said they "wept for days"
when they saw the picture. She said, "The photo
reminds us pregnancy isn't about disability or an
illness, it's about a little person."
Samuel was born in perfect health, the operation
100 percent successful.
"Picture of the Decade." It won't be.
In fact, unless you obtained a copy of the US
paper which published it, you probably would never have
seen it. The picture is that of a 21-week-old unborn
baby named Samuel Alexander Armas, who is being
operated on by surgeon named Joseph Bruner.
The baby was diagnosed with spina bifida and
would not survive if removed from his mother's womb.
Little Samuel's mother, Julie Armas, is an obstetrics
nurse in Atlanta. She knew of Dr. Bruner's remarkable
surgical procedure. Practicing at Vanderbilt
University Medical Center in Nashville, he performs
these special operations while the baby is still in
the womb.
During the procedure, the doctor removes the
uterus via C-section and makes a small incision to
operate on the baby. As Dr. Bruner completed the
surgery on Samuel, the little guy reached his tiny,
but fully developed hand through the incision and
firmly grasped the surgeon's finger.
Dr. Bruner was reported as saying that when his finger was grasped,
it was the most emotional moment of his life, and that
for an instant during the procedure he was just
frozen, totally immobile.
The photograph captures this amazing event with
perfect clarity. The editors titled the picture, "Hand
of Hope." The text explaining the picture begins, "The
tiny hand of 21-week-old fetus Samuel Alexander Armas
emerges from the mother's uterus to grasp the finger of Dr. Joseph Bruner as
if thanking the doctor for the gift of life."
Little Samuel's mother said they "wept for days"
when they saw the picture. She said, "The photo
reminds us pregnancy isn't about disability or an
illness, it's about a little person."
Samuel was born in perfect health, the operation
100 percent successful.
-- Political Pistachio Conservative News and Commentary
Sunday, February 17, 2019
DEMS to GOP: Comply, or Be Prosecuted ... just ask Roger Stone
By Douglas V. Gibbs
Author, Speaker, Instructor, Radio Host
The Democrat Party has become worse than the mafia.
Remember when Dinesh D'Souza was jailed for something a list of Democrats walked for?
How about Congressman Steve Stockman, persecuted, attacked legally over and over, until they were finally able to essentially jail him on administrative technicalities.
Then there is the story of Roger Stone. Illegally persecuted, illegal search and seizure in direct violation of the 4th Amendment, and then cuffed and detained.
It was a pre-dawn raid by the FBI of his Florida home that led to his subsequent arrest. He dared to stand against the Democrats, and question special counsel Mueller, and in response 29 FBI agents in full tactical gear, with CNN tipped off and ready to televise the whole thing, Stone was targeted, and arrested, labeled guilty before proven innocent, without due process.
Like with Trump, it was an investigation seeking a crime. Gestapo tactics. He gave a voluntary testimony about the 2016 presidential campaign to Congress, and since it didn't fit the Democrat Party's narrative, they targeted him through the deep state, and the FBI.
Roger Stone, with his wife and small dogs in his home, somehow warranted a SWAT operation in plain view of the leftwing's mainstream media minions, who were camped out across the street from Stone's house because they "got a tip."
FBI agents swarmed the property and surrounded Stone's entire home in bulletproof vests and night vision goggles as if he was some verified terrorist or heavily armed mobster. The pounding on the door was vicious enough to awaken Stone's wife Nydia, who is hearing impaired. The small dogs barked. Roger Stone opened the door and found himself looking down the barrel of two assault rifles. A helicopter flew overhead and an amphibious FBI unit pulled up into the canal behind the house as if the whole situation was in a war zone behind enemy lines in some other country.
Roger was handcuffed and carted off, for daring to speak out to Congress against the Democrats.
Force was used to apprehend the alleged perpetrator of non-violent process crimes. No prior criminal record, not a gun owner. But, the Democrats pulled out a full SWAT operation to arrest him.
It was a scene out of a movie. The NET. Enemy of the State. George Orwell's 1984. Any movie about World War II's Nazis or the Cold War's communists. True tyranny.
They couldn't get him on what they assumed he'd be guilty of, so they searched and searched until they discovered something. There are so many laws on the books, we are all guilty of something. Stand against them, and they will find those things, and throw the book at you. Roger Stone found out the hard way. They used statutes, little known laws of process, and brought charges they almost never use. It was an emergency. It had to be done. Stone dared to stand against the overlords of the Democrat Party.
The same tactics are being used against our duly elected President. He does not fit their agenda, and even threatens to tear it down, so Trump must be eliminated. Mueller is a part of their heavy handed tyranny. Comply with their agenda, or you will be prosecuted, and destroyed. That, my friends, is what the Democrats are best at, and what they are doing now to eliminate those who stand against them, and to cover up and hide their own true illegal actions. They are the mob. They are the mafia. They are something worse than anything America has ever experienced.
Stand against them, and get noticed that you are doing so, and they will create fabricated charges against you, as well. Witnesses will be created and lie after being coached. That is what they did to D'Souza, Stockman, Trump, and Roger Stone. Stand against them, and you may be next.
Donald Trump defeated them, and has vowed to disassemble the establishment, and they are out of their minds crazy in their attempt to stop him, and reverse what they, at first thought, was only an aberration.
Except, Trump is more than an aberration. If America stands firm behind him, he'll be around a long time.
Everyone around Trump has been targeted. They are being pressured to make false claims about President Trump or face the consequences. The media has convinced a number of Americans to hate Trump, but if you ask them, they can't tell you why.
They have Robert Mueller running roughshod over our legal system and trampling our basic fundamental rights as Americans. Due process has gone out the window, and as they were with Kavanaugh, and everyone else they hate, from the Democrat Party's point of view, anyone who is not in their camp does not have the right to be innocent until proven guilty.
This is what they do, and if we don't fight them, and defeat them, you could be next.
-- Political Pistachio Conservative News and Commentary
Author, Speaker, Instructor, Radio Host
The Democrat Party has become worse than the mafia.
Remember when Dinesh D'Souza was jailed for something a list of Democrats walked for?
How about Congressman Steve Stockman, persecuted, attacked legally over and over, until they were finally able to essentially jail him on administrative technicalities.
Then there is the story of Roger Stone. Illegally persecuted, illegal search and seizure in direct violation of the 4th Amendment, and then cuffed and detained.
It was a pre-dawn raid by the FBI of his Florida home that led to his subsequent arrest. He dared to stand against the Democrats, and question special counsel Mueller, and in response 29 FBI agents in full tactical gear, with CNN tipped off and ready to televise the whole thing, Stone was targeted, and arrested, labeled guilty before proven innocent, without due process.
Like with Trump, it was an investigation seeking a crime. Gestapo tactics. He gave a voluntary testimony about the 2016 presidential campaign to Congress, and since it didn't fit the Democrat Party's narrative, they targeted him through the deep state, and the FBI.
Roger Stone, with his wife and small dogs in his home, somehow warranted a SWAT operation in plain view of the leftwing's mainstream media minions, who were camped out across the street from Stone's house because they "got a tip."
FBI agents swarmed the property and surrounded Stone's entire home in bulletproof vests and night vision goggles as if he was some verified terrorist or heavily armed mobster. The pounding on the door was vicious enough to awaken Stone's wife Nydia, who is hearing impaired. The small dogs barked. Roger Stone opened the door and found himself looking down the barrel of two assault rifles. A helicopter flew overhead and an amphibious FBI unit pulled up into the canal behind the house as if the whole situation was in a war zone behind enemy lines in some other country.
Roger was handcuffed and carted off, for daring to speak out to Congress against the Democrats.
Force was used to apprehend the alleged perpetrator of non-violent process crimes. No prior criminal record, not a gun owner. But, the Democrats pulled out a full SWAT operation to arrest him.
It was a scene out of a movie. The NET. Enemy of the State. George Orwell's 1984. Any movie about World War II's Nazis or the Cold War's communists. True tyranny.
They couldn't get him on what they assumed he'd be guilty of, so they searched and searched until they discovered something. There are so many laws on the books, we are all guilty of something. Stand against them, and they will find those things, and throw the book at you. Roger Stone found out the hard way. They used statutes, little known laws of process, and brought charges they almost never use. It was an emergency. It had to be done. Stone dared to stand against the overlords of the Democrat Party.
The same tactics are being used against our duly elected President. He does not fit their agenda, and even threatens to tear it down, so Trump must be eliminated. Mueller is a part of their heavy handed tyranny. Comply with their agenda, or you will be prosecuted, and destroyed. That, my friends, is what the Democrats are best at, and what they are doing now to eliminate those who stand against them, and to cover up and hide their own true illegal actions. They are the mob. They are the mafia. They are something worse than anything America has ever experienced.
Stand against them, and get noticed that you are doing so, and they will create fabricated charges against you, as well. Witnesses will be created and lie after being coached. That is what they did to D'Souza, Stockman, Trump, and Roger Stone. Stand against them, and you may be next.
Donald Trump defeated them, and has vowed to disassemble the establishment, and they are out of their minds crazy in their attempt to stop him, and reverse what they, at first thought, was only an aberration.
Except, Trump is more than an aberration. If America stands firm behind him, he'll be around a long time.
Everyone around Trump has been targeted. They are being pressured to make false claims about President Trump or face the consequences. The media has convinced a number of Americans to hate Trump, but if you ask them, they can't tell you why.
They have Robert Mueller running roughshod over our legal system and trampling our basic fundamental rights as Americans. Due process has gone out the window, and as they were with Kavanaugh, and everyone else they hate, from the Democrat Party's point of view, anyone who is not in their camp does not have the right to be innocent until proven guilty.
This is what they do, and if we don't fight them, and defeat them, you could be next.
-- Political Pistachio Conservative News and Commentary
Saturday, February 16, 2019
Constitution Radio: State of Emergency
Constitution Radio with
Douglas V. Gibbs: Saturday at
1:00 pm Pacific, KMET 1490-AM
○ First Hour: Constitution Radio with Doug, Alex, and Dennis discuss issues through the lens of the U.S. Constitution, with Alan Myers joining us late in the hour for a discussion regarding the monetary system.
○ Second Hour: Conservative Voice Radio with Doug, Glenn, Jan, and Diane to discuss the issues from a Tea Party perspective
KMET 1490-AM
1-3 pm on Saturday Afternoon
archived podcast at https://soundcloud.com/kmet-1490-am/sets/constitution-radio
Did you miss the program last Saturday? Listen HERE.
Douglas V. Gibbs: Saturday at
1:00 pm Pacific, KMET 1490-AM
○ First Hour: Constitution Radio with Doug, Alex, and Dennis discuss issues through the lens of the U.S. Constitution, with Alan Myers joining us late in the hour for a discussion regarding the monetary system.
○ Second Hour: Conservative Voice Radio with Doug, Glenn, Jan, and Diane to discuss the issues from a Tea Party perspective
KMET 1490-AM
1-3 pm on Saturday Afternoon
archived podcast at https://soundcloud.com/kmet-1490-am/sets/constitution-radio
Did you miss the program last Saturday? Listen HERE.
Friday, February 15, 2019
A Valentine's Day to Remember ...
By Douglas V. Gibbs
Author, Speaker, Instructor, Radio Host
I suppose I've always kind of been somewhat of a romantic. But, romance takes money, and I'm usually not swimming in cash. Five years ago I injured my back, neck, and right shoulder in a hit and run incident on a job site while I was delivering road base in a sand and gravel truck (a "transfer" for those of you familiar with the industry). I received time off work to heal, but the injuries were severe enough that they knocked me out of being able to work doing the kinds of jobs that had dominated my adult-life (truck driving and construction). Unfortunately, the very skillful lawyers representing the company I worked for at the time of the accident made a very convincing argument that I was full of lies, and that my injuries were an attempt to commit fraud against the Worker's Compensation system. Since then I have been unable to work a day job for an employer, I face certain limitations daily due to the chronic pain I have had since the accident, and the challenges have been piling up in ways that I could not even explain. I currently live without health insurance, or a reasonable income. Therefore, my income now comes from what used to essentially be a hobby . . . my constitution classes, books, and speaking engagements.
My wife works a lot of overtime since my hobby becoming my job has dropped our income significantly. I teach one hour constitution classes a couple times per week, I teach homeschool students government (or economics, depending on which semester we are in) one day per week for about an hour and a half, I am a public speaker, a radio host on Saturdays (broadcasting nearly all of my shows from my home office, through a connection to the radio station, since driving each week has become more physically difficult and expensive), and I write books. Fortunately, the last book, 7 Worst Constitutional Liars, and a few other blessed circumstances, did enough for me in 2018 that for the first time since my injuries I made more money than I spent.
That's right, my constitution efforts have been in the red for a number of years, but last year we did well enough to show some profit. As a result, I set aside some of that money and decided to surprise my wife for Valentine's Day.
Last Thursday Night (February 14, Valentine's Day) I was scheduled to be a speaker at the Banning-Beaumont-Cherry Valley Tea Party's monthly dinner meeting (second Thursday of each month), and I convinced my wife to spend the Valentine's Day dinner with me at that event. I usually make a hundred bucks, or so, at that event, so not being one to stand in my way to make a little money, she agreed.
Knowing that a massive rainstorm was coming, and also wanting to get away from the noise of life, I told her that we would be staying at Casino Morongo's hotel (located in Cabazon, which is about an eleven minute drive from the Farms' House Restaurant in Banning, the location of the Tea Party's event) on Wednesday and Thursday Night. Between the money I have made recently, and the money I would likely make at the Tea Party meeting, I explained to her, there should be enough to get away and just relax in the hotel room.
Considering that when I got injured, to help us pay the mortgage on our house, my son, his wife, and their three children moved into our house with us, and the grandkids (God Bless Them) are a noisy bunch, the time away was good news for her to hear. She was all in.
However, she worked on Wednesday, and would not get off of work until 9:30 pm, so we would be checking in late on our first night.
Which was exactly as I wanted it.
After finishing class with my homeschool group Wednesday afternoon, I cancelled the Wednesday Night Constitution Class in Temecula. Then, I went up to Cabazon to check-in, and prepare the room. The trip up, which took a bit more than its usual hour, consisted of hammering rain, gusty winds, and to say the least, the trip was harrowing. I passed a few accidents, and blazing lights and sirens were the norm, rather than the rare exception.
The drive up there, if I wish to keep the actually miles driven to a minimum, consists of quite a few back-roads, and very little freeway driving. The 215 freeway to the 60 or the 10 are huge loops, and the more direct route is up Winchester Road from Temecula through Hemet, a quick jaunt along Domenigoni Parkway, Warren, and across Ramona Expressway to Sanderson Avenue, which leads to a stretch of treacherous and zig-zagging highway through an area of the "badlands" called "Lamb's Canyon."
The road through the canyon between San Jacinto and Beaumont requires careful driving as it is, but with heavy rain (coming down so hard it was in buckets rather than drops), the trip was difficult. Visibility was very limited, yet as I slowly worked my way through the treacherous conditions, smaller kid-cars flew by me without a care in the world.
Once to the top, I hit a few stores to pick up roses, a couple bottles of wine, various candies (her favorites, Hershey bars with almonds and a large flat of Ferrero Rocher candies, along with an assortment of heart shaped stuff). I already had some little plastic heart emojis to spread across the room, and an endearing card with a message I knew would make her melt, from the day before.
When I got to the hotel the rain was even heavier than before. I parked, braved the rain, and checked in. I explained to the lady at the counter what I wanted to do, and that if I didn't have help, or some kind of cart on wheels, it would take multiple trips between the room and my car. Plus, thanks to the weather, and a phone call earlier I had to make to my credit union, I was pressed for time.
She smiled, and told a young man about my predicament. "Do you have your valet parking receipt?" he asked.
"No, I'm in the casino lot."
"Oh," he said. "If you are staying in the hotel, valet parking is complimentary, as is my assistance. We are here to serve you. Tell you what, get your car, and I will meet you in the valet area."
The rain lightened up as I walked to my car, but it suddenly became a vicious downpour as I got in line for the valet. The gentleman met me with a cart. We loaded everything on the cart for a single trip to the room, off we went. The roses had beads of water on them that actually made them look better. Everything else was in thick grocery bags, and he positioned them in such a way that the insides were protected from the rain.
18 floors later, we arrived at my room, he helped me unload, I gave him a tip, and I went to work. I was wishing I could take a nap afterward. It was more work than I had expected, and my back was screaming for mercy.
Then, after I got back to my car, which they left nearby at the valet since I told them I would be less than twenty minutes, I braved the rainy storm down the hill to retrieve my wife.
The rain came down even harder. The sky darkened. I had to slow down quite a bit just to assure myself I was going to live during this part of my back and forth journey.
As I drove down the hill, she called me to tell me she had gotten off work early. The timing was not good, for I had pushed my time allotment, and was going to arrive at 9:30 pm as originally told she would be off work. However, due to the rain, and a reduction in the number of customers, she expected to be off work at around 9:00 pm.
Fortunately, she did not have to spend the half hour in the rain. She instead spent the time chatting with co-workers in the employee lounge.
My wife is a very serious individual, and when we arrived at Casino Morongo she was a little bothered with me when I took the lead ahead of her, and then struck a path along the casino floor that did not point towards the hotel registration desk. "Doug," she called to me, "where are you going? Check-in is over there."
I ignored her, just as I did in the car when she asked during the trip up the road, "What did you do all day?"
"Doug? Doug?"
I picked up the pace, and she said less as she began to concentrate on just keeping up. I had my bag and computer firmly clutched in my hands, she carried her bag and a couple items on hangers, and as I approached the hotel entrance on the far side of the casino floor I showed the security guard my key for entry in such a way that my body blocked her view.
"Where are you going, Doug!"
I hit the elevator button, and luckily a door opened rapidly. With not enough time to protest, nor tell the guard her husband was either lost, or crazy, she entered the elevator with me, and I punched the button for floor 18.
Then, we approached the room. Still confused, she asked, "what are you doing? How is it that you have that key?"
I slipped the card key home. "This," I said, smiling, "is how."
The door opened, and before her on the bed, the desk, and a mantle near the window were two dozen roses in two vases (a dozen in each), one pink, the other red, plastic red heart-shaped emojis all over the place (two dozen), the candies, the wine (with glasses), and so forth.
"This," I finally answered her question, "is what I did all day."
Then, contrary to her usual vacation mode during which she normally keeps us so busy I need a vacation from my vacation afterward, we relaxed, and did just about nothing but watch television, play backgammon, and play other games with each other.
Afterward, she complimented me on the whole two night affair, and was regretting having to return to work on Friday, or go home to the noisy hustle and bustle of our life.
I used to do things like this a lot back when we were younger, but my income was greater back then, than it is, now. One thing I can say about romance ... it ain't cheap. But, this expense was well worth it. Best Valentine's Day we've had in a long time.
-- Political Pistachio Conservative News and Commentary
Author, Speaker, Instructor, Radio Host
I suppose I've always kind of been somewhat of a romantic. But, romance takes money, and I'm usually not swimming in cash. Five years ago I injured my back, neck, and right shoulder in a hit and run incident on a job site while I was delivering road base in a sand and gravel truck (a "transfer" for those of you familiar with the industry). I received time off work to heal, but the injuries were severe enough that they knocked me out of being able to work doing the kinds of jobs that had dominated my adult-life (truck driving and construction). Unfortunately, the very skillful lawyers representing the company I worked for at the time of the accident made a very convincing argument that I was full of lies, and that my injuries were an attempt to commit fraud against the Worker's Compensation system. Since then I have been unable to work a day job for an employer, I face certain limitations daily due to the chronic pain I have had since the accident, and the challenges have been piling up in ways that I could not even explain. I currently live without health insurance, or a reasonable income. Therefore, my income now comes from what used to essentially be a hobby . . . my constitution classes, books, and speaking engagements.
My wife works a lot of overtime since my hobby becoming my job has dropped our income significantly. I teach one hour constitution classes a couple times per week, I teach homeschool students government (or economics, depending on which semester we are in) one day per week for about an hour and a half, I am a public speaker, a radio host on Saturdays (broadcasting nearly all of my shows from my home office, through a connection to the radio station, since driving each week has become more physically difficult and expensive), and I write books. Fortunately, the last book, 7 Worst Constitutional Liars, and a few other blessed circumstances, did enough for me in 2018 that for the first time since my injuries I made more money than I spent.
That's right, my constitution efforts have been in the red for a number of years, but last year we did well enough to show some profit. As a result, I set aside some of that money and decided to surprise my wife for Valentine's Day.
Last Thursday Night (February 14, Valentine's Day) I was scheduled to be a speaker at the Banning-Beaumont-Cherry Valley Tea Party's monthly dinner meeting (second Thursday of each month), and I convinced my wife to spend the Valentine's Day dinner with me at that event. I usually make a hundred bucks, or so, at that event, so not being one to stand in my way to make a little money, she agreed.
Knowing that a massive rainstorm was coming, and also wanting to get away from the noise of life, I told her that we would be staying at Casino Morongo's hotel (located in Cabazon, which is about an eleven minute drive from the Farms' House Restaurant in Banning, the location of the Tea Party's event) on Wednesday and Thursday Night. Between the money I have made recently, and the money I would likely make at the Tea Party meeting, I explained to her, there should be enough to get away and just relax in the hotel room.
Considering that when I got injured, to help us pay the mortgage on our house, my son, his wife, and their three children moved into our house with us, and the grandkids (God Bless Them) are a noisy bunch, the time away was good news for her to hear. She was all in.
However, she worked on Wednesday, and would not get off of work until 9:30 pm, so we would be checking in late on our first night.
Which was exactly as I wanted it.
After finishing class with my homeschool group Wednesday afternoon, I cancelled the Wednesday Night Constitution Class in Temecula. Then, I went up to Cabazon to check-in, and prepare the room. The trip up, which took a bit more than its usual hour, consisted of hammering rain, gusty winds, and to say the least, the trip was harrowing. I passed a few accidents, and blazing lights and sirens were the norm, rather than the rare exception.
The drive up there, if I wish to keep the actually miles driven to a minimum, consists of quite a few back-roads, and very little freeway driving. The 215 freeway to the 60 or the 10 are huge loops, and the more direct route is up Winchester Road from Temecula through Hemet, a quick jaunt along Domenigoni Parkway, Warren, and across Ramona Expressway to Sanderson Avenue, which leads to a stretch of treacherous and zig-zagging highway through an area of the "badlands" called "Lamb's Canyon."
The road through the canyon between San Jacinto and Beaumont requires careful driving as it is, but with heavy rain (coming down so hard it was in buckets rather than drops), the trip was difficult. Visibility was very limited, yet as I slowly worked my way through the treacherous conditions, smaller kid-cars flew by me without a care in the world.
Once to the top, I hit a few stores to pick up roses, a couple bottles of wine, various candies (her favorites, Hershey bars with almonds and a large flat of Ferrero Rocher candies, along with an assortment of heart shaped stuff). I already had some little plastic heart emojis to spread across the room, and an endearing card with a message I knew would make her melt, from the day before.
When I got to the hotel the rain was even heavier than before. I parked, braved the rain, and checked in. I explained to the lady at the counter what I wanted to do, and that if I didn't have help, or some kind of cart on wheels, it would take multiple trips between the room and my car. Plus, thanks to the weather, and a phone call earlier I had to make to my credit union, I was pressed for time.
She smiled, and told a young man about my predicament. "Do you have your valet parking receipt?" he asked.
"No, I'm in the casino lot."
"Oh," he said. "If you are staying in the hotel, valet parking is complimentary, as is my assistance. We are here to serve you. Tell you what, get your car, and I will meet you in the valet area."
The rain lightened up as I walked to my car, but it suddenly became a vicious downpour as I got in line for the valet. The gentleman met me with a cart. We loaded everything on the cart for a single trip to the room, off we went. The roses had beads of water on them that actually made them look better. Everything else was in thick grocery bags, and he positioned them in such a way that the insides were protected from the rain.
18 floors later, we arrived at my room, he helped me unload, I gave him a tip, and I went to work. I was wishing I could take a nap afterward. It was more work than I had expected, and my back was screaming for mercy.
Then, after I got back to my car, which they left nearby at the valet since I told them I would be less than twenty minutes, I braved the rainy storm down the hill to retrieve my wife.
The rain came down even harder. The sky darkened. I had to slow down quite a bit just to assure myself I was going to live during this part of my back and forth journey.
As I drove down the hill, she called me to tell me she had gotten off work early. The timing was not good, for I had pushed my time allotment, and was going to arrive at 9:30 pm as originally told she would be off work. However, due to the rain, and a reduction in the number of customers, she expected to be off work at around 9:00 pm.
Fortunately, she did not have to spend the half hour in the rain. She instead spent the time chatting with co-workers in the employee lounge.
My wife is a very serious individual, and when we arrived at Casino Morongo she was a little bothered with me when I took the lead ahead of her, and then struck a path along the casino floor that did not point towards the hotel registration desk. "Doug," she called to me, "where are you going? Check-in is over there."
I ignored her, just as I did in the car when she asked during the trip up the road, "What did you do all day?"
"Doug? Doug?"
I picked up the pace, and she said less as she began to concentrate on just keeping up. I had my bag and computer firmly clutched in my hands, she carried her bag and a couple items on hangers, and as I approached the hotel entrance on the far side of the casino floor I showed the security guard my key for entry in such a way that my body blocked her view.
"Where are you going, Doug!"
I hit the elevator button, and luckily a door opened rapidly. With not enough time to protest, nor tell the guard her husband was either lost, or crazy, she entered the elevator with me, and I punched the button for floor 18.
Then, we approached the room. Still confused, she asked, "what are you doing? How is it that you have that key?"
I slipped the card key home. "This," I said, smiling, "is how."
The door opened, and before her on the bed, the desk, and a mantle near the window were two dozen roses in two vases (a dozen in each), one pink, the other red, plastic red heart-shaped emojis all over the place (two dozen), the candies, the wine (with glasses), and so forth.
"This," I finally answered her question, "is what I did all day."
Then, contrary to her usual vacation mode during which she normally keeps us so busy I need a vacation from my vacation afterward, we relaxed, and did just about nothing but watch television, play backgammon, and play other games with each other.
Afterward, she complimented me on the whole two night affair, and was regretting having to return to work on Friday, or go home to the noisy hustle and bustle of our life.
I used to do things like this a lot back when we were younger, but my income was greater back then, than it is, now. One thing I can say about romance ... it ain't cheap. But, this expense was well worth it. Best Valentine's Day we've had in a long time.
-- Political Pistachio Conservative News and Commentary
Thursday, February 14, 2019
Political Corruption and Ballot Harvesting: MTRA
Friday Night: Joshua Matrisciana of Jeremiah Films discussing Political Corruption and Ballot Harvesting. The following video with Douglas V. Gibbs as one of the interviewees will be shown at the event (in the video I throw a strong call to action to the churches, by the way):
Censor Busters - Ballot Harvesting & Political Corruption from Jeremiah Films on Vimeo.
Censor Busters - Ballot Harvesting & Political Corruption from Jeremiah Films on Vimeo.
Wednesday, February 13, 2019
Pass Area Tea Party Meeting: Reaching Hispanic Voters
Join Us on Thursday . . . Valentines Day, 4:30 pm check-in, 5:00 pm sharp for start of the evening's program.
Farms' House Restaurant, 6261 Joshua Palmer Way, Banning, CA
and bring your honey !!!
Farms' House Restaurant, 6261 Joshua Palmer Way, Banning, CA
and bring your honey !!!
Trump Weighs Signing Compromise Budget and Border Wall Bill
![]() |
| Singer Joy Villa's 2019 Grammy Awards "Build the Wall" dress |
Author, Speaker, Instructor, Radio Host
Normally, when it comes to politics, I don't like the word "compromise." My cynicism towards the "C" word is not because I don't believe we should be willing to compromise, but because in politics the word usually means that the GOP lost ground, and the Democrats got what they wanted. In other words, the Democrats don't compromise, but they will throw that word around when they reach what they believe to be a change that will allow the country to lurch further to the left.
When it came to Trump's border security wall the Democrats laid down the gauntlet. They huddled behind Nancy Pelosi who proclaimed, only "a dollar for the wall."
Then, suddenly, the Democrats offered a bill with some of the money Trump wants for his border wall ... well, at least it's much more than a buck.
Did they ... GULP ... compromise?
The Democrats have been running the numbers, and the reality is, most Americans want border security. An open border stance by the Democrats is not a very popular stance, and if they are totally unwilling to work with the President regarding the border wall, they will lose the House, and not even come close to gaining the White House, in 2020.
On the same token, if President Trump signs the current proposed deal on the table, even if it is only a fraction of what he wants in the long run, he did not lose, either. A part of negotiating is getting what you can with the hopes of getting all of it in the long run, even if it takes doing it in chunks.
NBC News reports that the new proposed agreement provides nearly $1.4 billion for 55 miles of new border fencing, which could include steel slats and other "existing technologies," and an additional $1.7 billion for other Homeland Security priorities like new technology and more customs personnel. Additionally, Democrats dropped a demand to cap the number of beds for illegal aliens detained within the country by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).
If Trump signs it, he didn't lose, he simply settled for just a part of what he wants, for now. We can always go back to the table for more in the future.
If he doesn't sign the bill, we go back into government shutdown-ville, which Trump has not necessarily been losing, but he may if we got back into that type of situation, again.
-- Political Pistachio Conservative News and Commentary
Tuesday, February 12, 2019
Corona Constitution Class: Legal Amendments, Continued
Tuesday Night 6:00 pm at AllStar/CARSTAR Collision
522 Railroad St., Corona, CA
Constitution Class Handout
Instructor: Douglas V. Gibbs
Lesson 15
The Legal Amendments
Amendment IV
Warrants, Searches, and Seizures
The 4th Amendment to the United States Constitution was added as part of the Bill of Rights on December 15, 1791. It was written with the purpose of protecting people from the government searching their homes and private property without properly executed search warrants.
"The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized."
What this means is that the federal government, in order to search a person's home, business, papers, bank accounts, computer or other personal items, in most cases, must obtain a search warrant signed by the proper authority, which usually means by a judge.
The issuance of a warrant must accompany reasonable belief that a crime has been committed and that by searching the premises of a particular location, evidence will be found that will verify the crime. The government officer does not have to be correct in his assumption, he just has to have a reasonable belief that searching someone's private property will yield evidence of the crime. The task of determining whether or not the officer's assumptions are a reasonable belief falls on the judge who is considering issuing the search warrant.
The concept that citizens must be protected from unreasonable searches and seizures goes back into English history. The British Crown was known for performing searches and seizures that were unlawfully conducted. Often, these searches were conducted by the king's representatives.
The British government saw the American Colonies as a source of revenue. As a result, taxation against the American colonies was a continuous practice, in the hopes of generating as much money from the colonists as possible. The colonists resented this and engaged in substantial smuggling operations in order to get around the customs taxes imposed by the British government.
The King responded to the Colonist's smuggling activities by using writs of assistance, which were search warrants that were very broad and general in their scope. British agents, once obtaining these writs, could search any property they believed might contain contraband goods. They could enter someone's property with no notice and without any reason given. Tax collectors could interrogate anyone about their use of goods and require the cooperation of any citizen. Searches and seizures of private property based on very general warrants became an epidemic in colonial America.
In 1756, the Massachusetts legislature passed search and seizure laws outlawing the use of general warrants. The friction created between the Royal Governor and the people of Massachusetts grew with each passing moment.
In 1760 James Otis, a Boston lawyer, strongly objected to these arbitrary searches and seizures of private property and consequently resigned his position with the government, and then became the lawyer for a group of over 50 merchants who sued the government claiming that the writs of assistance were unjust.
James Otis represented these merchants for free. His speech condemning British policies, including writs of assistance and general search warrants, was so powerful and eloquent, that it was heard of throughout the colonies and catapulted him to a place of leadership in the swelling tide of disillusionment toward Great Britain.
Twenty-five year old John Adams, who would become the second president of the United States some time later, was sitting in the courtroom and heard Otis' famous speech that served as a spark that led to igniting the American Revolution.
The 4th Amendment, a part of The Bill of Rights, became law on December 15, 1791.
The 4th Amendment applies only to the federal government. State constitutions are written similarly, and States also have laws that are consistent with the intention of the 4th Amendment. The 4th Amendment provides protection from illegal search and seizure by federal government officials, but not by private citizens. So, if an employer unreasonably searched your possessions at work, the 4th Amendment would not have been violated, but local laws may have been.
In recent history The PATRIOT Act was seen as a breach of the 4th Amendment because it allowed the federal government to pursue a number of strategies in their search for terrorists that includes warrantless phone taps, access to phone logs, and monitoring of online communications such as email. The debate still goes on regarding the constitutionality of The PATRIOT Act, with both sides presenting reasonable arguments, ranging from the constitutional necessity of the law for the purpose of "providing for the common defense," to the argument that the authorities offered by the law allows the federal government to unconstitutionally intrude on the right to privacy of all Americans.
The National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) of 2014 builds on the powers seized by the federal government through the PATRIOT Act, allowing unrestricted analysis and research of captured records pertaining to any organization or individual "now or once hostile to the United States." The definition of "hostile to the United States" is broad, and can include political opposition. Under NDAA 2014 Sec. 1061(g)(1), an overly vague definition of captured records enhances government power and guarantees indefinite surveillance.
The Internal Revenue Service is another arm of the federal government that routinely violates the 4th Amendment, doing so under the auspice of ensuring all taxes are paid.
Terms:
Search Warrant - The Search Warrant specifically requires that the government demonstrate to a judge the existence of probable cause of criminal activity on the part of the person whose property the government wishes to search. The Fourth Amendment commands that only a judge can authorize a search warrant.
Writs of Assistance - British search warrants that were very broad and general in their scope. British agents, once obtaining these writs, could search any property they believed might contain contraband goods.
Questions for Discussion:
1. What actions by the British prior to the American Revolutionary War inspired the Founding Fathers to include this amendment in the Bill of Rights?
2. How would our legal system act if Search Warrants were not considered necessary?
3. How does the Fourth Amendment influence today's thinking regarding government actions, such as with The PATRIOT Act?
Resources:
How Congress Has Assaulted Our Freedoms in the Patriot Act by
Andrew P. Napolitano, Lew Rockwell.com: http://www.lewrockwell.com/orig6/napolitano2.html
Joseph Andrews, A Guide for Learning and Teaching The Declaration of
Independence and The U.S. Constitution - Learning from the Original Texts Using Classical Learning Methods of the Founders; San Marcos: The Center for Teaching the Constitution (2010).
Paul A. Ibbetson, Living Under the PATRIOT Act: Educating a Society;
Bloomington, IN: Author House (2007)
Philip B. Kurland and Ralph Lerner, The Founder's Constitution -
Volume Five - Amendments I-XII; Indianapolis: Liberty Fund (1987).
Amendment V
Due Process and Eminent Domain
Due Process
The majority of the Fifth Amendment provides additional reinforcement to the concept of due process. The language of this Amendment was designed to assure those who feared the potential tyranny of a new centralized government created by the United States Constitution that the federal government would be restrained in such a way as to ensure that the government did not perpetrate bloodshed against its citizens.
The first part of the 5th Amendment reads: "No person shall be held to answer for a capital crime, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury. . ."
The 5th Amendment attests to the Founding Father's understanding that this is a nation of property owners. As a republic of property owners, when in jeopardy of legal trouble, our rights and properties must be safeguarded. Therefore, an American Citizen in the American legal system has a right to a jury, as well as a right to the presentation of evidence. Conviction is not reached with a majority vote, either. Conviction requires a unanimous agreement among all of the members of the jury. These concepts reinforce the concept that one is innocent until proven guilty (A concept found in the Book of Deuteronomy, Chapter 19, Verse 15), and that the United States of America is a Republic. Mob rule is not allowed, for as the amendment provides, a person cannot be held until given the opportunity of due process.
Not all persons, however, are awarded this opportunity. The next part of the amendment reads: ". . . except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or in the militia, when in actual service in time of War or public danger. . ."
The military does not fall under the U.S. Constitution. Personnel serving in the armed forces are governed by the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ). Instead of a civilian trial, a military service member is normally afforded a court martial. If a civilian trial is deemed appropriate by the U.S. Military, a service member can still stand trial in a civilian court, but the military has the authority to decide whether or not the member shall stand such a trial.
Having a sense of independence, individuals must be protected, then, from the tyrannical trappings of a governmental system that may try to use the judiciary against them (as the King of England had done often). The protective mechanism, or the rule of law, would be the U.S. Constitution and clauses like the 5th Amendment, which were designed to provide protection to the populace from unfair legal practices.
One such protection is provided in the next part of this amendment: ". . . nor shall any person be subject for the same offence to be twice put in jeopardy of life and limb. . ."
Protection against Double Jeopardy enables us not to be continuously tried for the same offense, which was a technique often used in some parts of Europe during the eighteenth century. The idea was that if a person was prosecuted enough, either they would weary of the process and break down, or the defendant would become unable to financially continue, hence unable to defend themselves.
The next part of the amendment serves as a large influence on today's Miranda Rights. The section reads: ". . . nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property."
Miranda Rights are named after the U.S. Supreme Court case, Miranda v. Arizona (1966). Miranda Rights are a warning given advising the accused of their right to remain silent, their right to an attorney, and the right to an appointed attorney if they are unable to afford counsel - prior to conducting a custodial interrogation. From the 5th Amendment: ". . .nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law." Miranda Rights exist to secure the 5th Amendment's privilege against self-incrimination, and to make the individual in custody aware not only of the privilege, but also of the consequences of forgoing it. The judicial opinion from the Miranda v. Arizona case also indicated that in order to protect the person's life, liberty or property with the due process of law, the individual must have the right to an attorney. With a lawyer present the likelihood that the police will practice coercion is reduced, and if coercion is nevertheless exercised the lawyer can testify to it in court. The presence of a lawyer can also help to guarantee that the accused gives a fully accurate statement to the police and that the statement is rightly reported by the prosecution at trial.
The words of the Founders continues to resonate today as the majority of the American people seem to firmly agree with the Founding Father's insistence that no one should be deprived of life, liberty, or property without due process of law. We can take satisfaction that most of our fellow citizens in our republic still hold these truths to be self-evident.
Eminent Domain
The provisions of the 5th Amendment are there to keep our courts honest, and the powers of the government constrained. The last phrase of the 5th Amendment, however, is considered too general by many, and it has been used in a manner by the federal government that is extremely troublesome, because it gives the government the right to take property if there is just compensation.
How is just compensation determined? Is it based on the market value of the property? How does the government officials involved in eminent domain calculate the non-intrinsic value? How do they compensate for the value on which nobody can put a price?
Just compensation was intended to be based on what the property owner deemed to be just. If the property owner did not deem the offer to be just compensation, then the government, from a constitutional viewpoint, is out of luck.
Terms:
Capital Crime - A crime for which the punishment is death. Punishment for a Capital Crime is called Capital Punishment.
Double Jeopardy - The act of putting a person through a second trial for an offense for which he or she has already been prosecuted or convicted.
Due Process - The essential elements of due process of law are notice, an opportunity to be heard, the right to defend in an orderly proceed, and an impartial judge. It is founded upon the basic principle that every man shall have his day in court, and the benefit of the general law which proceeds only upon notice and which hears and considers before judgment is rendered. In short, due process means fundamental fairness and substantial justice.
Eminent Domain - The power to take private property for public use by a State, municipality, or private person or corporation authorized to exercise functions of public character, following the payment of just compensation to the owner of that property.
Grand Jury - A group of citizens convened in a criminal case to consider the prosecutor's evidence and determine whether probable cause exists to prosecute a suspect for a felony. At common law, a group of persons consisting of not less than twelve nor more than twenty-four who listen to evidence and determine whether or not they should charge the accused with the commission of a crime by returning an indictment. The number of members on a grand jury varies in different States.
Infamous Crime - A crime which works infamy in the person who commits it. Infamous crimes tend to be classified as treason, felonies, and any crime involving the element of deceit.
Just Compensation - The value of a property deemed to be just by the property owner.
Miranda Rights - A warning given advising the accused of their right to remain silent, their right to an attorney, and the right to an appointed attorney if they are unable to afford counsel - prior to conducting a custodial interrogation.
Mob-Rule - A government ruled by a mob or a mass of people; the intimidation of legitimate authorities; the tyranny of the majority; pure democracy without due process.
Republic - Form of government that uses the rule of law through a government system led by representatives and officials voted in by a democratic process. The United States enjoys a Constitutional Republic.
Rule of Law - The restriction of the arbitrary exercise of power by subordinating it to well-defined and established laws; Laws of Nature and of Nature's God; self-evident standard of conduct and law.
Questions for Discussion:
1. How is property rights affected by Due Process?
2. Why do military members not fall under the protections of the U.S. Constitution?
3. Why is protection against Double Jeopardy important?
4. What was the inspiration for our Miranda Rights?
5. Who determines if compensation for one's property is just?
6. How is Eminent Domain being used for environmental reasons?
7. Is Eminent Domain constitutionally in force if a property is rezoned for environmental conservation, forcing the value of the property to be reduced due to the fact that it can no longer be developed?
8. Is it constitutional for government to use Eminent Domain for the use of the land by private development projects?
Resources:
Definition of Due Process, Family Rights Association:
http://www.familyrightsassociation.com/bin/definition_due_process_.htm
Joseph Andrews, A Guide for Learning and Teaching The Declaration of
Independence and The U.S. Constitution - Learning from the Original Texts Using Classical Learning Methods of the Founders; San Marcos: The Center for Teaching the Constitution (2010).
Philip B. Kurland and Ralph Lerner, The Founder's Constitution -
Volume Five - Amendments I-XII; Indianapolis: Liberty Fund (1987).
U.S. Supreme Court case, Miranda v. Arizona, 384 US 436 (1966)
http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/scripts/getcase.pl?court=US&vol=384&invol=436
Amendment VI
Personal Legal Liberties
The 6th Amendment affords criminal defendants seven discrete personal liberties. "In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury of the State and district wherein the crime shall have been committed, which district shall have been previously ascertained by law, and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation; to be confronted with the witnesses against him; to have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses in his favor, and to have the Assistance of Counsel for his defence."
Rights afforded in all criminal prosecutions are set forth in this amendment. The word "all" at the beginning of this amendment establishes a special characteristic regarding this article of the Constitution. The Constitution applies only to the federal government, unless it states otherwise. The 6th Amendment, by providing the word "all" in the regard to cases, establishes that this amendment is not only to be applied to the federal courts, but to the State, and lower, courts as well.
As for the rights afforded to the accused:
Speedy Trial
The concept of a speedy trial was an English concept of justice. A speedy trial allows for conditions that disallow the powerful from abusing the court system, forcing defendants to languish in jail for an indefinite period while awaiting their trial. Ensuring a speedy trial minimizes the time in which a defendant's life is disrupted and burdened by a criminal proceeding, and reduces the likelihood of a prolonged delay impairing the ability of the accused to prepare a defense.
Historically, when trials are postponed or drag out for long periods of time, witnesses disappear, and evidence is often lost or destroyed. Memories of the incident in question are also not as reliable as time passes.
A person's right to a speedy trial arises after the arrest, indictment, or otherwise formal accusation of a crime.
Public Trial
The right to a public trial was inherited by the Americans from Anglo-Saxon jurisprudence. Public criminal proceedings would operate as a natural check against malevolent prosecutions, corrupt judges, and perjurious witnesses. A trial that is out in the open also aids the fact-finding mission of the judiciary by encouraging citizens to come forward with relevant information.
The right to a public trial is not absolute. Persons who may disrupt proceedings may be banned from attending the trial because they present a substantial risk of hindering a trial. A disallowance of the media attending falls under the concept of "potential disruptions," but otherwise, under normal circumstances, both the public and media have a qualified First Amendment right to attend criminal proceedings. The right to a public trial does not require the presence of media, and because courtrooms have limited seating, judges may attempt to maintain decorum. For media, with today's technology, the media does not have to be in the courtroom to see or hear the proceedings of the case.
Right to Trial by an Impartial Jury
A part of the effort in achieving an impartial jury is the process of determining who will serve on the jury through a series of questions and observations, in an effort to eliminate biased jurors. The concept of protecting the defendant from a biased jury can be traced back to the Magna Carta in 1215. In the United States, the requirement for a trial by an impartial jury does not apply to juvenile delinquency proceedings, or to petty criminal offenses, which consist of crimes punishable by imprisonment of six months or less. In Great Britain, and Canada, a jury is not required for cases with potential penalties of two years or less, and the concept of an impartial jury is not entertained in the same way as in the United States. Canada and Britain choose jurors randomly, and then in an open court the jurors for a specific case are selected from the jury panel by ballot. A juror may be challenged once in the box for bias, but an extensive process to eliminate possible biased jurors before selection through a series of questions and observations is not normal practice.
The Sixth Amendment entitles defendants to a jury that represents "a jury of the defendant's peers," which means the jury should be a fair cross section of the community. From the jury pool, the presiding judge, the prosecution, and attorneys for the defense are allowed to ask members of the jury pool a variety of questions intended to reveal any latent biases, prejudices, or other influences that might affect their impartiality. The presence of even one biased juror is not permitted under the Sixth Amendment.
It is possible that the potential bias of a juror may be affected by sources outside the courtroom, so jurors are instructed to not consider newspaper, television, and radio coverage before or during trial, and are instructed not to discuss the trial with even family members, when evaluating the guilt or innocence of the defendant.
Jurors are not permitted to begin deliberations until all of the evidence has been offered. Deliberations do not begin until after the attorneys have made their closing arguments, and the judge has read the instructions. Premature deliberations have shown the potential, historically, to create early biases, or a juror may form a preconceived notion that they will then compare all evidence to, which they may have entertained as a result of premature deliberations.
Notice of Pending Criminal Charges
The 6th Amendment guarantees defendants the right to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation against them. Defendants must receive notice of any criminal accusations that the government has lodged against them through an indictment, information, complaint, or other formal charge. Defendants may not be tried, convicted, or sentenced for a crime that materially varies from the crime set forth in the formal charge.
The requirement by the 6th Amendment to inform a defendant of the nature and cause of the accusation is an attempt by the Founding Fathers to create fundamental fairness that was not necessarily present in civil and criminal proceedings in England and the American colonies under English common law. Receiving notice of pending criminal charges in advance of trial permits defendants to prepare a defense in accordance with the specific nature of the accusation. In tyrannies, defendants are all too often incarcerated without being apprised of pending charges until the trial begins. Requiring notice of the nature and cause of the accusation against a defendant eliminates confusion regarding the basis of a particular verdict, which in turn decreases the chances that a defendant will be tried later for the same offense.
Confrontation of Witnesses Against Him
The 6th Amendment requires that defendants have the right to be confronted by witnesses who offer testimony or evidence against them, as well as the opportunity to subject them to cross-examination.
Today's courts have established rules that are enforced at the discretion of the judge who forbids questioning that pursues areas that are irrelevant, collateral, confusing, repetitive, or prejudicial. Defendants are also forbidden to pursue a line of questioning solely for the purpose of harassment.
Compulsory Process for Obtaining Witnesses In His Favor
The 6th Amendment recognizes a defendant's right to use the compulsory process of the judiciary to subpoena witnesses that may be favorable to the defense. Courts may not take actions to undermine the testimony of a witness who has been subpoenaed by the defense. Any law that attempts to establish particular persons as being incompetent to testify on behalf of a defendant is not allowed.
Defendants can also testify on their own behalf, a right not afforded in the American Colonies, or Great Britain, prior to the United States dissolving the political bands connecting them to the Crown. Common law presumed all defendants to be incompetent to give reliable or credible testimony on their own behalf. The vested interest in the outcome of the trial, it was believed, would taint the testimony of the defendant. The 6th Amendment does not require, a defendant to testify on his own behalf, but does not prohibit it, either.
Right to Counsel
The 6th Amendment states that criminal defendants have a Right to Counsel. A defendant's right to counsel does not become an issue until the government files formal charges. However, in the 5th Amendment a person has the right not to be compelled to be a witness against himself, allowing him to remain silent until he has counsel present.
In many instances, defendants have the inability to obtain counsel be it because of financial or other reasons. The 6th Amendment, by listing that assistance of counsel for his defense is a right, has compelled the government to institute a program where counsel can be assigned to a defendant if the person is unable to afford counsel, or obtain counsel for any other reason. In the occurrence of a defendant unable to afford counsel, the trial judge appoints one on his behalf. If it turns out that the defendant has financial resources previously unknown to the court, he may be required to reimburse the government for a portion of the fees paid to the court-appointed lawyer.
Defendants are not required to have counsel. Defendants have a right to counsel. Defendants also have the right to decline the representation of counsel and proceed on their own behalf. Defendants who represent themselves must present a waiver of the 6th Amendment right to counsel before a court will allow them to do so. The waiver must reveal that the defendant is knowingly making the decision, and understands the potential consequences.
Questions for Discussion:
1. Why is having a speedy trial so important in a free society?
2. How does a public trial better enable the fact-finding mission of the trial?
3. How is the concept of an impartial jury different in the United States than it is in other countries?
4. Why is it important for a defendant to be able to confront the witnesses against him?
5. How is a defendant's right to counsel enabled in today's court system?
Resources:
Joseph Andrews, A Guide for Learning and Teaching The Declaration of
Independence and The U.S. Constitution - Learning from the Original Texts Using Classical Learning Methods of the Founders; San Marcos: The Center for Teaching the Constitution (2010).
Philip B. Kurland and Ralph Lerner, The Founder's Constitution -
Volume Five - Amendments I-XII; Indianapolis: Liberty Fund (1987).
Amendment VII
Right of Trial by Jury in Civil Suits
"In suits at Common Law, where the value in controversy shall exceed twenty dollars, the right of trial by jury shall be preserved, and no fact tried by a jury, shall be otherwise reexamined in any court of the United States, than according to the rules of the common law."
The 7th Amendment guarantees the right to a jury trial in most civil suits heard in federal court. Remember, the Constitution, and the Bill of Rights, apply only to the federal government unless the document states otherwise. The 7th Amendment serves to preserve the historic line separating the province of the jury from that of the judge in civil cases by separating cases that should have a jury in federal court, from those that are smaller cases, and may not require a jury. During the time the amendment was ratified, a case requiring a jury was one where "the value in controversy" exceeded twenty dollars. The cutoff in the court system today is $75,000. Any disputes that involve amounts less than $75,000, in fact, will not even be handled in a federal court.
State courts don't have to honor this provision in the 7th Amendment, and often don't. People bringing a suit do not have to have a jury trial. Individuals can waive their right to a jury trial if they so choose.
The 7th Amendment also expressly forbids federal judges to re-examine any "fact tried by a jury" except as allowed by the common law. This means that no court, trial or appellate, may overturn a jury verdict that is reasonably supported by the evidence.
Prior to the Declaration of Rights in 1689, English judges served the King of England. These judges showed bias towards the King, resulting in unfair rulings. Judges in the American colonies were also biased towards the king, and when King George III got rid of trials by juries in the Colonies, the colonists viewed the decision as more kindling for the fire of independence that had been blazing in the pubs, churches and meeting halls of the Colonies. The Bill of Rights applied what the Framers learned under the rule of Britain to the American System. In the American courts the Framers believed it was important to have a fair court system, so the right to have a trial by jury is mentioned a number of times, and is a fundamental part of the United States legal system.
Together with the due process clause of the 5th Amendment and the right to an impartial jury enumerated in the 6th Amendment, the 7th Amendment guarantees civil litigants the right to not just a jury, but to a jury who is not biased for any reason.
Terms:
Bill of Rights - The first ten amendments of the U.S. Constitution; a formal summary of those rights and liberties considered essential to a people or group of people.
Declaration of Rights - Enacted in 1689, the English Bill of Rights is one of the fundamental documents of English constitutional law, marking a fundamental milestone in the progression of English society from a nation of subjects to a nation of free citizens with God-given rights. The evolution began with the Magna Carta in 1215.
Questions for Discussion:
1. What historic line does the 7th Amendment preserve?
2. Must the States abide by the 7th Amendment?
3. Can a person bringing suit waive the right to a jury trial?
Amendment VIII
Excessive Bail, Cruel and Unusual Punishment
The 8th Amendment reads, "Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted."
As a nation founded on honorable Judeo-Christian principles, the United States legal system is expected to be fair and just. This means that Americans should insist upon a due process that protects individuals from excesses and abuses by the judicial system. Such expectations include that no individual should be singled out, or treated differently, in the eyes of the courts. A fair and equitable judicial system includes no excessive bails or fines, or cruel and unusual punishment, for one person while others guilty of similar crimes do not receive similar treatment.
Today's definitions attempt to set a limit on where "excessive" or "unusual" lies. When a harsh penalty is applied for a crime, even when it is similar to the punishment received by others for the same crime, challenges are launched regarding if the penalty matches the crime. These challenges are fine, and an important part of the American judicial system seeking to adjust itself in regards to its fairness, but the debates during the Federal Convention and State ratification conventions did not focus so much on where the line between excessive and not excessive, or unusual as opposed to usual, exists as much as are the bails, fines and punishment consistent with the bails, fines and punishment consistent with others guilty of the same.
Questions for Discussion:
1. In the context of the time period during which the 8th Amendment was written, what was meant by "cruel and unusual punishment?"
2. How has the original definition of "cruel and unusual punishment" changed since the founding of the United States?
3. How does the 8th Amendment apply the concept of uniformity to cases?
4. Why would the Founding Fathers see the need to enumerate the right of an individual to be protected from cruel and unusual punishment?
Resources:
Joseph Andrews, A Guide for Learning and Teaching The Declaration of
Independence and The U.S. Constitution - Learning from the Original Texts Using Classical Learning Methods of the Founders; San Marcos: The Center for Teaching the Constitution (2010).
Philip B. Kurland and Ralph Lerner, The Founder's Constitution -
Volume Five - Amendments I-XII; Indianapolis: Liberty Fund (1987).
Copyright 2015 Douglas V. Gibbs
|
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)









